Last weekend I finished watching HBO Max’s “Lanterns” (Kyle Chandler, Aaron Pierre), and this weekend I finished Amazon Prime’s “Carrie” (Summer H. Howell). Both of these series are based on previously-adapted material from beloved sources, and each consists of 8 episodes.
The similarities do not stop there. Both series explore similar themes: social standing, psychologically abusive relationships, love, the conflicting natures of good & evil that exist in all of us, the consequences of our actions to ourselves, and how those decisions can also impact others. Both shows utilize a non-linear format to varying degrees. Both are light on action and special effects, choosing instead to focus on character development. I applaud them equally in that regard.
However, in terms of narrative structure and pacing, “Carrie” significantly outshines “Lanterns”. As a longtime fan of all things Green Lantern, it pains me to award this show second place.
“Lanterns” started off strong but wained a bit each successive week, until fizzling out with a disappointing finale. In contrast, “Carrie” started softly and steadily gained intensity each episode, leading to a surprisingly well done finale.
Stephen King’s novel has been adapted into a movie three times before, so Carrie’s blood-soaked telekinetic rampage at the prom is well known. The fact that the show runners were able to expand upon the material, and make the finale an “edge of your seat” experience is a true testament to their skill as storytellers (not to mention the stellar performances by the entire cast). This is the first time on screen that Carrie’s mother (Samantha Sloyan) felt like a real human being, and not just a caricature of a religious zealot.
Both shows conclude in an open-ended way, leaving the door open to the possibility of another season. “Lanterns” has the potential to learn from its mistakes and perhaps make something more palatable to longtime Green Lantern fans. I believe “Lanterns” could only improve. “Carrie”, if continued, would be in uncharted territory, and a second season would be completely outside of King’s source material. That could go either way.
I actually do recommend both series, but if you had to choose just one… go with “Carrie” (just don’t go with her to the prom).
